How To Protect Your Tax Refund From the Trustee



Posted: Monday, October 11, 2010

by Michael Goldstein, Esq.
Goldstein and Clegg LLC

When someone who is facing financial difficulty decides to file for bankruptcy there are many secondary choices they must make. They may be able to decide which chapter of bankruptcy they should file, Chapter 7 liquidation or Chapter 13 reorganization. Once that decision has been made the Debtor then needs to decide, should they keep their home; should they keep their boat? Depending on their income and assets though the biggest choices typically revolves around their more liquid assets though. Which assets should they protect from the Trustee in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case, and which ones should they expose.

In many situations there is no choice, due to the fact that a cap has been hit on an asset, such as a bank account, lost wages in a law suit or equity in a car. However, one such asset that is typically very difficult to exempt, unless a Debtor uses the Federal exemptions and has a wild card available is an anticipated or even realized tax refund. Under 11 U.S.C. 542(a), any property that the Debtor held prior to filing his or her bankruptcy becomes property of the estate and is subject to turnover to the Trustee upon request.

In the past, if a Debtor has money owed to him from the Internal Revenue Service, such an asset must be listed on Schedule B of the bankruptcy petition and generally, the Trustee will look to take those funds as part of the liquidated bankruptcy estate, or demand that the unsecured Creditors be paid at least that amount in a Chapter 13 plan based upon the B22 analysis. This was true until very recently when an ingenious Debtor, James Winslow Graves and his bankruptcy attorney beat the system. You see, a Trustee is only entitled to demand an asset which the Debtor has a right to. This is no different then the legal theory "you can only give title to what you own". What this Debtor did was simply allow the IRS to take his tax refund and hold it in their possession until such time as he may need to pay taxes in the future. Now this may sound almost like a fraudulent transfer, but the IRS code is very clear on the matter. Under the tax code, once a tax payer elects to leave those funds on deposit with the United States and apply the overpayment to his or her future tax liability, that decision is irrevocable, or as my six year old child would say, "no take backs"! More specifically, the tax code states, "no claim for credit or refund of such overpayment shall be allowed for the taxable year in which the overpayment arises." 26 U.S.C. 6513(d).

The Trustee in this case argued the position that the refund amount was property of the estate under 11 U.S.C. 541(a)(1), and that, since Debtors were receiving the benefit of the application of the refund, the funds should be treated as an account receivable of the Debtors, and Debtors should therefore be required to turn over an equivalent amount to the estate. However, both the Bankruptcy Court and the 10th Circuit Federal Court held that the tax code is clear and specific in its language and intent. The courts held the Debtor once he filed his taxes, had no rights to the tax refund and as a result could not "take it back". If you find yourself in a similar position, The Florida case of In Re Graves, Docket Number. 08-1462 and In re Graves, 396 B.R. at 73 is the case to cite. The Creditors and the Trustee may think it unfair and even borderline deceptive, but the courts have spoken with its full opinon.

This article on how to protect your tax refund from the Bankrutpcy Trustee was drafted by Attorney Michael Goldstein, a Massachusetts bankruptcy lawyer
This Article has been viewed 399 times. (Not updated in real-time.)
No comments yet.
We want your comments! If you can read this, you don't have javascript enabled, so you can't use this comment system. Please enable javascript.